LAL OS: Heavy Accusations in the View of Technical Criticism, Our Corporate Grievance and Public DisclosureWe know the challenges of developing an operating system. However, the damages that may be caused by targeting engineering work with fraud and criminal organization implications without any technical examination should be taken as seriously as technical problems. It is not easy to develop an operating system from scratch in Turkey. You write your own kernel, memory management, and graphics engine. Then one day, in a public forum, you see your company accused of 'fraud' and 'being associated with a foreign criminal organisation'. And while your right to defend has been taken away... here's what we at QBS are going through. QBS Software and Information Technologies October 27, 20261. Why did we have to make this statement? As QBS Software and Information Technologies, we have been developing independent operating system technologies with our own resources and engineering studies for a long time. LAL OS is not a project that emerged with the name change or visual customization of an existing Linux distribution. It is an independent operating system initiative where we work on its own kernel, memory management, task scheduler, graphics engine, desktop environment and system services. We do not hide that we are still in the development phase. We have unfinished properties. We continue to work on hardware compatibility, system stability and application ecosystem. We have no objection to criticism of our technical deficiencies. However, on October 24, 2026, the post made by the user named Sadi Soft in Pardus Forums contained statements that exceeded the limits of technical evaluation. Our company was associated with the risk of fraud without showing any concrete events or documents. It was even suggested that a foreign criminal organization might come out behind us. It was also noteworthy that the owner of the post said that he may have exaggerated after these statements. We are no longer talking about a criticism of an operating system, but about heavy criticisms that may affect the commercial reputation of a company and the reliability of the technology it develops. Related post: https://forum.pardus.org.tr/t/yerli-diye-tanitildigi-icin-yaziyorum-lal-os-isletim-sistemi /33669/32. How can they be published in a forum related to the state's technology project? One of the most thought-provoking aspects of this event is the platform where the sharing is made. Cardus is an operating system project developed with public resources in Turkey and continued within TÜBİTAK BİLGEM. Cardus Forums, which can be accessed through the official website of this project, have exchanged information with software users and technology enthusiasts. for this reason, the impact of the statements published in the forum cannot be considered as a personal discussion between only two users. Statements written about a technology company can also be found through search engines; they can be read by students, academics, investors, public employees and potential business partners researching the project. A verified visitor to the forum about how many people enter the forum daily s we do not have a month. However, it is clear that such claims, which are published in a public and accessible platform by search engines, are likely to reach far beyond their first readers. An unfounded criminal insinuation made in a technology forum may not be limited to the day it is posted. It can also come across someone who is researching the project months or years later.That's why content auditing is important.What do the forum's own rules say? The rules of the Pardus Forums dated May 4, 2026 prohibit insulting or defamatory statements about insulting posts and other operating systems. The same rules state that inappropriate content can be flagged and reported to the management and moderators have the authority to intervene. the rules also state that messages are not approved one by one before they are published. Therefore, the publication of a message at the first moment and its examination afterwards are different issues. Our question here is clear: Why a software company is associated with the possibility of fraud and foreign criminal organization without showing concrete evidence on a platform that prohibits defamatory statements in its own forum rules remains public ? We don't know what moderation reviews this post actually went through. We also don't claim that management consciously approves. But on public platforms, moderation isn't just about deleting inappropriate words. It is also the evaluation of the possible damages that a post may cause to the reputation, labor and commercial relations of third parties. The fact that the forum is related to a state-sponsored technology project does not turn user comments into the official opinion of the state. However, the institutional reliability of such a platform increases the extent to which published heavy accusations will be taken seriously and the importance of moderation decisions.3. What grievance have we faced as QBS? To say that this event is just a disturbing comment would be to underestimate its impact.QBS is a company that develops multiple software products today; conducting engineering studies in the fields of ERP, CRM, operating system, energy management and programming language.Continue promotion of the products we have developed, customer relations, academic interviews, investment evaluations and business partnership studies in such a period, the association of our company with the possibility of fraud on a public technology platform has created a reputation problem that directly affects us. Damage to our reputation When a potential customer or business partner investigates QBS, he/she may encounter a claim that is not based on any technical examination. It is not necessary for that person to accept the claim as true. Just being suspicious can change the course of the business negotiation.Risk to joint venture and investment relationshipsTrust in technology companies is as important as the product.A business to purchase a software license, a dealer to enter into a joint venture, or an organization evaluating a technology investment may be affected by public claims about the company's reliability.Any sale or investment was lost due to this sharing today b we can't handle it. Therefore, we do not present an unrealized loss as if it had occurred. However, it is clear that such claims pose a danger to commercial trust relations. Our engineering time is devoted to defense. Developing an operating system requires serious time and concentration. Our main activity is to develop cores, solve memory problems, improve task management, and mature drivers and desktop system. Despite this, engineering work it has forced our company to take additional time to prepare a response to heavy criticisms that are not directly related to our company, to make a statement and to inform the public. This is one of the concrete effects of the incident. We suffer not because we are criticized, but because we are forced to defend the reliability of our company instead of technical work. 4. We wanted to respond; this time, our forum account was silenced. We created an account with the corporate identity of QBS to participate in the forum and explain the related claims. However, although there were no posts published in our account, we were restricted by the system. A silencing notification was shown on the account screen because the new user typed too quickly. We also encountered problems in the email verification processes. Automatic security of this restriction mechanism, system configuration or any other transaction. We do not claim that any person or manager intentionally silenced us. However, the result does not change: While the allegations about our company can be read publicly, QBS could not use the opportunity to make a statement in the same environment. While there are statements targeting the reliability of our company on one side, moment, the inability of the addressee to respond has created a serious imbalance in the public discussion. Our expectation from the forum management is to explain why our account was silenced, to correct any erroneous automated transaction, and to examine the relevant post within the framework of its own forum rules.5. Danger of heavy claims due to lack of technical knowledgeWe do not expect anyone to develop operating system kernels or know low-level system programming.A Linux user can also ask about the operating system. A student may also question the authenticity of the product. A user may also find the introductory text exaggerated. These are usual. However, it is different for the person to make a final judgment on issues that he/she does not technically confirm, then target the company's reliability with criminal statements without any concrete evidence. The danger we want to draw attention to here is not the technical ignorance itself, but the public circulation of claims that exceed the limits of information and evidence. For example, the source code is open does not mean that the operating system is built on another kernel. The fact that Turkish translations have not been completed does not mean that the kernel has not been developed independently. The fact that a technology company has not yet announced its new residential address does not mean that the dealership activities are fraudulent. Each of these inferences is based on the misassociation of different issues. The real danger is that these inferences are personal is transformed from conviction to public crime. The sarcastic style used in the sharing and the subsequent acceptance of exaggeration do not eliminate the possible effects of the allegations. The reputation of a company is not a subject to be tested by personal predictions or sarcastic expressions. A wrong technical interpretation can be corrected. However, the implication of a serious public crime can leave a mark on people's memory and search results even after it has been corrected. This danger applies not only to QBS, but to all attempts to develop new technology in Turkey.6. How have we responded to the interest of Pardus users so far?Here, we would like to share an important fact with the public. Those who want to get information about LAL OS do not only consist of our own followers. Previously, people who used Linux, including Pardus users, reached us through our company's WhatsApp communication line, e-mail addresses and phone channels. How LAL OS was developed, which business etim system base, the current development stage and when it can be used. We also answered these questions to the extent of our accessibility. We considered this communication as an indicator of technological interest and community curiosity, not a threat. There were people who asked technical questions or did not agree with some of our preferences as well as those who supported the project. We did not prevent the critics from asking questions. We have not closed our doors to those who are curious about our technology. Because developing domestic technology is not just about producing code. Communicating with people, explaining the stage of the system and sharing information with the technical community is part of this. This is one of the main reasons why we developed the Social Academy platform. We want to create an environment where we can share information about LAL OS, Motif and other software works directly from the source, where developers can ask questions and contribute.https://qbs.com.tr/sosyalakademi/7. Technical response to allegations: What is LAL OS really? LAL OS, which we share with the public, is an operating system project that we have developed on its own system layers. The current work includes boot, kernel, memory management, task scheduler, graphics infrastructure, compositor, window system, desktop and local applications. Our main areas of development are: LAL Kernel: System initialization, basic resource management and kernel infrastructure.B hand management and BigArena: Separation of core and user areas, memory ownership, and management of large graphic resources.Task scheduler: Execution of running tasks, management of task contexts, and application lifecycle.ZuzuGraphic: Framebuffer, drawing surfaces, graphic contexts, and component-based imaging.Compositor: Merging window surfaces, layer order, and redraw operations.Mosaic Desktop: Desktop, start tici, window management and local user experience.System applications: Gerrok, LALedit, Terminal, system settings and diagnostic tools.Motif: The programming language we are working on for the local software development ecosystem.All these areas continue to develop at different maturity levels. In particular, I am working on the capture of application errors without disturbing the stability of the kernel and the controlled termination of the application. z is in progress. We do not present all of this as a completed, certified, or publicly available operating system claim. We do not have a publicly available ISO deployment today. Our current main development line is on 32-bit; our 64-bit architectural work is on the roadmap. However, the fact that the system is not yet ready for end-user deployment does not mean that there is no development version running in the middle.8. Not being open source does not equal not being nativePardus is a Debian GNU/Linux-based operating system. We care about its contributions to the open source ecosystem in Turkey. LAL OS follows a different development model. We are working on an operating system whose basic system layers are developed within QBS and whose source codes are protected within our company's intellectual property structure. The fact that a software is developed locally and its source codes are accessible to everyone is not the same concept. Related to open source, licensing and distribution rights independent development is about the architecture and codebase on which the system is built. It is not technically correct to ignore this distinction and claim that a technology project is not real because only the source code is not published. Our company address and technocity interviewsIn the comment in the forum, it was also criticized that the physical address of our company was not included in detail on our website. We would like to give public information on this issue. As QBS, we are conducting negotiations to move our technology development activities to the university and technocity/technopark environment. We expect these negotiations to be concluded in terms of corporate placement. We are still waiting for a full allocation of an unconfirmed place. we don't want to explain it like a pussy. Likewise, we do not find it appropriate to show an institution whose negotiations are ongoing as the technocity where we are officially settled. However, this process does not eliminate the obligation to make our current official company address and legal contact information available to the public as required. We acknowledge that we need to improve the information on our corporate website. Waiting for the results of the Teknokent interviews is a corporate transition process; it is not an indicator of fraud or illegal activity. A company's business assets and activities should be assessed by official records and verifiable documents, not estimates.10. Our call to the forum management and the technology communityOur expectation from the management of the Cardus Forums is that the issue should not be examined as a personal dispute, but as a serious content complaint regarding the commercial reputation of our institution. The issues we want to be explained are certain: Have the statements linking our company to the possibility of fraud and criminal organization been examined within the framework of the forum's own content rules? Which assessment, if any, has been examined so has been reached? Why is the relevant content publicly accessible? Why was the QBS corporate account, which has no published posts, silenced? How can we use our corporate right of reply in the same forum environment? Asking these questions does not mean that we are against the Pardus project or the entire Pardus community. On the contrary, technical criticism and unproven criminal implications for the credibility of technology communities are differentiated. we are open to anyone who wants to discuss the architecture of LAL OS. We can discuss our core, memory model, task management, graphics engine, application architecture and development decisions. However, we do not accept these discussions to be conducted through insults, ridicule or criminal organization attributions. Conclusion: We will not make our victimization invisible. The reason for writing this article is not only to promote LAL OS. QBS, has been subjected to heavy public accusations due to a technology developed by him/her, he/she has needed to explain his/her corporate reliability in the face of the accessibility of these claims and has faced account restriction in his/her attempt to respond in the same forum. We want this victimization to be clearly seen. We do not claim commercial losses that have not yet been proven to occur. However, we state that the criminal allusions to our reputation, the time we have to separate from our engineering studies and the difficulty we have in responding are real. Turkey needs not only to use existing technologies, but also people who develop new technologies. It is natural for these people to question their engineering studies. However, the method of questioning should be information, documents, tests and technical discussion. Criticizing a technology you can move. You may find an architecture inadequate. You may overestimate the promotion of a product. However, you cannot target its developers with fraud or criminal organization implications without providing any evidence. We will continue to develop LAL OS. We will share real working images, technical progress, problems we encounter and our engineering solutions with the public. Our goal is not only to develop an operating system developed in Turkey, but also to develop its own kernel, tools, programming language and software ecosystem. contribute to an engineering culture. We are open to criticism. We are ready for technical verification. But we will not normalize the targeting of our labor and corporate reputation with accusations without evidence.QBS Software and Information TechnologiesLAL OS Development TeamLAL OS: https://qbs.com.tr/urunler/lal-os/SosyalAkademi: Relevant post on https://qbs.com.tr/sosyalakademi/KaynaklarPardus forum: https://forum.pardus.org.tr/t/yerli-diye-tanitildigi-icin-yaziyorum-lal-os-isletim-sistemi/33669/3Pardus Forum Rules: http://forum.pardus.org.tr/t/forum-kur allari/32795Official corporate introduction of Cardus: https://pardus.org.tr/hakkimizda/